Many years ago, Benj and I put together a holiday mix album, entitled “Who Spiked the Egnnog?” This started an obsessive need to collect Christmas songs and albums outside of the mainstream Bing Crosby and Burl Ives you hear all November and December while you shop.
Rather than burn a CD, I thought I’d share thirteen favorites. One for each of the thirteen days of Christmas. (I did tell you this wasn’t a mainstream collection, right?) Plus one bonus mini-song.
All the songs are linked to the Amazon MP3 store so you can download them and play ‘em on your favorite player or burn ‘em to a CD. So don’t worry about whether you have an iPod, Sansa, Zune, or none of the above. You can listen.
Enjoy!
The Pogues: The Fairytale of New York
Quite possibly the best Christmas song ever. It gets to the very heart of what it means to be blessed, lucky and loved at Christmas time. And it means not being a drunk in the tank every single holiday, filled with regret and shattered dreams. Merry Christmas! You can buy the song here, of course.
Sting: Gabriel’s Message
I’m not one to get too into angels and Jesus and such too much as Christmas time. I celebrate a Santa-heavy holiday. But this haunting and powerful techno-choir performance is just fantastic. Get it, listen to it, listen to it again.
Dar Williams: The Christians and the Pagans
A great song about a family that finds common ground on the holidays despite accusations of godlessness and witchcraft. Trite until you get to the line “Because when Christians sit with Pagans only pumpkin pies are burning.” Spend a buck to enjoy it.
The Pretenders: 2000 Miles
This song doesn’t end up on enough holiday album lists because, well, it isn’t on a holiday album. Doesn’t change the fact that it’s a lovely song about separated lovers during the holidays. And then there’s Chrissie Hynde’s lovely voice singing it. You don’t have to go 2000 miles to download it, though.
Elvis Presley: Santa Bring my Baby Back
Elvis’s Christmas album is a family favorite. It’s so hard to pick just ONE song from the album (Blue Christmas and Here Comes Santa Claus are the other front-runners), but I have to pick this one as the one most quintessentially Elvis-sounding. See what you think.
Sarah McLachlan Happy X-Mas (War is Over)
Great cover of Lennon’s classic, which is quite timely now (and will be in the future, I’m afraid). Just beautiful. Listen here.
Straight No Chaser: 12 Days of Christmas
A hilarious medley of Christmas tunes sung by Indiana University’s a cappella group.
You can watch the video (which is possibly better than the song on its own) and you can buy the song here.
Boyz II Men: Let it Snow
I’m a sucker for singing in harmony, so the whole Boyz II Men Christmas album is one of my favorites. It doesn’t have any of the irritating jingle jangle schmaltz of the rest of ‘em. This is one of the many great songs on the album, but the rest are sure worth listening to. Download it in four-part-harmony.
Jonathan Coulton: Christmas is Interesting
If Straight No Chaser’s 12 days is a medley of songs, then this is Coulton’s medley of Christmas mythology. It conflates Jesus with Citizen Kane and compares Christmas to a knife in your heart. Not quite an accurate primer on all things holiday, but you can buy the song anyhow. Support your independent musicians, okay?
Tracy Chapman: O Holy Night
A classic, sung by one of the great folk vocalists. I just love it. Click to get it.
The Klezmonauts: Santa Gey Gezunderheit
Klezmer Christmas music? It must be THE KLEZMONAUTS! It’s a great album, but this song is especially enjoyable. It’s an original, it’s funny, and it seems to capture the Jewmass spirit. Get it!
Book of Love: Candy Carol
This song is so sweet and poppy that diabetics should steer well clear of it. I keep this album as a secret favorite, right next to my collection of the Spice Girls oeuvre. You know you want it!
The Kinks: Father Christmas
Definitely a counter-culture Christmas song. While the Pogues’ “Fairytale” is depressing and melancholy, this one’s about someone playing Santa getting mugged. But the underlying message is that the poor need more than toys, and that gift-giving Santa is only relevant to the rich girls and boys. I’ve been criticized for playing this song at Christmas, but asking Santa to “Give my daddy a job cause he needs one/ He’s got a lot of mouths to feed” seems entirely in keeping with the season, to me. Make up your own mind.
Bonus song! Barenaked Ladies: Deck the Stills
Okay, no way it’s in the top 10, but it’s clever and cute. Buy it here or just listen to the preview. It’s a 32 second song and you get a 30 second preview, so you do the math on that one. Enjoy.
The album also features very nice renditions of the Dreidel Song and Hannukah Oh Hannukah, for those of you looking for Jewish classics. Or head back to the Klezmonauts for your Yiddish holiday spirit.